Dispassionate Liberalism
HAS MOVED....CLICK HERE FOR NEW SITE

Intellectual freedom is the only guarantee of a scientific - democratic approach to politics, economic development, and culture.
-Andrei Dmitrievich Sakharov-

They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin-

Be excellent to each other.  -Bill and Ted-


"Where's My-Polling-Site-dot-Com?"




Mark Adams is [in no particular order] a Lawyer, Restauranteur, Husband, Father, Grandfather, Landlord, Singer, Guitarist, Political Scientist, Amateur Historian and Rhetorician with no sense of reverence for anything except the freedom to speak one's mind.
To visit Mark's Family Law Website
Click Here!
Google



Web D-Lib




this is a Proud Liberal Site
Proud Member of the Reality-Based Community
Trackback by HaloScan.com


Syndicate this site

Subscribe To My Podcasts


Blogroll Me!

Truth Laid Bear


BlogSearchEngine


Listed at:
Political Blog Directory
Political Blog List
Ohio weblogs on current events
Blog Directory Anti-Bush
Ohio - LeftyBlogs.com
American Street
Daily Kos :: Reader Blogs
Technorati

OHIO BLOGS

AsOhioGoes

Agora
An Age Like This
Blue Grass Roots
Bush Lies
Cincinnati Blog
Cincinnati Group
Cincinnati News
Cleveland Diary
Coins For Change
Covington
Dispassionate Lib
Democratic Veteran
Dr. Mike
GrowOhio
Hegemo's
Hypothetically Speaking !
It's In There
Jerry Springer for Ohio
Just Well Mixed
Logan's Lurch
Mad As Hell
Nosey Online
Ohio Voter Suppression
People Have The Power
Red Wheelbarrow
Shameless Agitator
Swing State Project
The Tomb of Horrors
Timroffia
Walk In Brain

TOLEDO BLOGS

Aaron Myers' Blog
Adventures of a Single Mom
Alan Barber
Arbor Update
CatchingFlies
Cloudstrife
Chuck Childers
Chili Dog Blog
Damage Inc
Dan Eble's Blog
Diana Schnuth
E2K Security
Erie Voices
Frank Szollosi
The Glitch
Grace Lutheran Church
Graphikjunkie
History Mike
Jean's Travels
Jeff Hormann
Joey Harrison
Josh Pollard
Keith Instone
Kelegraph
Kevin Marsh
Laura Rae Amos
Liberal Common Sense
Mark Dilley
Micah and Susan
Mindful Musings
Move the Crowd
My Ugly Divorce
Mind Matter
Omar the Great
One Bad Website
Rhea's Journal
Paul's Down Home Page
Photo Dan
Political Whore
Promote the Progress
Random Thoughts
The Rhetorical Box
Right moment
Ruckman.net
Rick Reed
Robin Gorrell's Blog
Sea4Yourself
A Short Domain Name
Small Business IP Protection and Management
Steve Solomon
The Age of Unreason
The Built Environment
Toledo Talk
Toledotastic
Trailing Thoughts
Traveling through Life Without a Map
Tribe's Rants
Untangled Vine
Urban Camel
Vince T
Ws84Tigers
The Yippie Show

BLOGS I RECOMMEND
A Fulmination of Thought
Agitprop, feat. Blogenfreude
A Tiny Revolution
Aaron Swartz
Al Franken Show
Allah Is In The House
American Agenda
AMERICAblog !
American Regression
American Street !
An Inclination to Criticize
Angry Liberal
Another Liberal Blog:
Approximately perfect
Arianna's Blog

Bear Left On Unnamed Road
Billmon
BlogBites
blogunderground
Blue Lemur
BlueGrassRoots
Bob
BOP News !
BRAD BLOG
Brandon Starr

Captain Normal
Castle Argghhh!
ConyersBlog
Corpus Callosum
Crooks and Liars
Cursor.org

Daily Kos !!
Daily Mislead
DemocracyArsenal
Dohiyi Mir !
Doucheblog

E Pluribus Unum !!
Eccentricity
Eschaton !!
Ezra Klein !

Fanatical Apathy
Firedoglake
Folkbum's !

Heli's Heaven and Hell Radio !
Hellblazer
Howler !
Huffington Post !!
Hullabaloo !!

Iddybud !
InstaPundit

Jesus' General
Juan Cole !!
JuliusBlog

LA Conservative
Last Word
Latest Poll Results
Lawyers, Guns and Money
League Of Liberals
Legal Fiction
LIBERAL FORUM
Logipundit.com
LOW RENT RAT

M E D L E Y
Mad As Hell (OH)
MAJORITY REPORT RADIO
Margaret Cho
Metafilter
Moderate Voice
morons.org - Engage Your Brain
MyDD !!


Obsidian Wings
O'Franken Factor

Pandagon  !
PNAC.info
Political Wire
Progressive Capitalist
Proof Through the Night

Queen of All Evil !!

Rational Liberal

ScrappleFace
Scriveners Lament
Shakespeare's Sister
Sideshow !
Sirotablog
Skeptical Notion

Skippy the bush kangaroo
Stockton & Tweed's Smorgasblog/
sustainablog

t a c i t u s
t r u t h o u t
talking dog
Talking Points Memo
Tao of Dowingba
Tar Baby
The FlipSide
THE FULCRUM
The Gantry Launchpad
The Nation
The Note
the RANT
Thunderstorms



Unspecified Chatter
VodkaPundit

Wage Slave Journal
Washington Monthly
White House
Wince and Nod
words mean things

Yellow Doggerel Democrat

Wednesday, March 15, 2006
Serious About Censure

  Russ Feigold's censure resolution has captured the imagination of the liberal blogosphere.  And why not?

After years of playing the victim, or taking sometimes solitary, albeit ineffectual protest stands against the GOP juggernaut, finally a Democrat has make a positive, pro-active move in opposition.

Will it be successful?  Who knows, probably not by the looks of things.  By getting the issue out there and measuring the support it garners, however, puts the hierarchy of the Democratic Party that "the times, they are a-change-in."

In a town addicted to kabuki dances and puppet theater, the censure resolution brings reality, and the brutal consequences of indulging in fantasy out in the open.  Every Senator, even enablers like Bill Frist know that if the Senators could vote their conscious, maybe by secret ballot instead of their position being subject to the predictable mudslinging that traditionally skews congressional action in favor of self-preservation ahead of the public good, the idea of putting the President on notice that he's gone too far would gain overwhelming support.

Certainly one of the main reasons they went so far against Bill Clinton was because they could count.  Never was there any question that they had the votes, let alone the legal justification to remove Clinton from office.  Nevertheless, they went forward with their Dog-And-Pony show.  It was captivating entertainment -- but the real power games, the real decisions in Washington don't occur on the Senate floor in front of cameras, but in the back of lobbyists' limos.

So it was with Nixon.  And the same bean counters are there today.

Majority Leader Frist and White House Spokes-Puppet Scotty McManiquin want to label this nothing more than a political stunt.

News Flash:  They're right.

Why impeach a President if you don't have the votes to remove him?  To further the political ambitions of those directing the play, of course.  No question that it did Lindsay Graham's career wonders.  These guys became household names.  In putting up a dogged defense against the impeachment sideshow, Chuck Schumer's career was fast-tracked as well.

None of it, none of the ridiculously long and expensive investigation of Clinton's marital infidelity had one damn thing to do with making this nation a better place.  Nothing.  It had everything to do with the petty power game that masquerades as our representative republic.

They never did and knew they never would have the votes to remove Bill Clinton from office.  They did, however, have the votes to censure him.  One man made the difference, Russ Feingold.

Feingold was the only Democrat who voted to give the evidence against Bill Clinton a fair hearing.  With him on board the GOP was assured to defeat a cloture vote.  Like his sole stand on the Patriot Act 1.0, he has built a reputation for acting on principle rather than politics and self-interest.

Not to diminish the fact that I sincerely believe that is how all of our representatives should behave, it's still a stunt.

Feingold didn't introduce a censure motion in the Senate as Schumer and the Dems in the House did as an alternative to impeachment.  Indeed, if the prospect of the impeachment stage-show were not looming and censure were the only thing on the table, both houses of Congress should have approved it by a nine to one margin, but the real vote would have gone down party lines -- in exactly the opposite way censure of Clinton was defeated. (See below for update)

They weren't serious about censure then.  Certainly part of that had to do with the fact that what the President was accused of wasn't all that serious.  They weren't serious about impeachment either, or they would have counted the votes and called it a day before the case got out of the House Judiciary Committee.  When they counted the votes in 1974, Nixon called it a day.

We all know of course, as does every US Senator, that at the very least the crimes of the Bush White House are censure worthy.  What they also know, that we only understand on an instinctive level, is that ad libbing is not something Washington politicians are prepared to do.  Certainly Bill Frist kept to his script, opposing His Royal Bushness helps our enemies.  The rest of the Democractic Party has yet to agree on their lines or who should play which part.

And they're right.  They know they can pander to the liberal wing of the party, just as they've been accused of doing to minorities for years, and ignore us.

Who else are we going to vote for?  Republicans?

As long as they cower, just enough; and act strong, just enough -- they're hoping against hope that the pissed-off left (who aren't going to vote against them and are too active to stay home) won't convince the independents and moderates to once again shun the Party.

To be sure there will be Republican blood-letting if we get a majority in one of the congressional chambers this November.  But we're going to eat our own either way -- win or lose -- because Russ Feingold has pointed a bright spotlight on the Democrat's so-called leadership.  He stood by himself against Patriot Act I, He was one of ten against Patriot Act II.  It looks like he's at least got Minority Leader Ried with him as well as Iowa's Harkin and probably, if push came to shove, at least another 15 Democratic Senators brave enough to vote their conscious -- certainly none of whom are facing reelection this year or have presidential ambitions, but you can't have everything. 

The tide is changing, though.


UPDATE:  It looks like Kevin Drum and I are of the same mind on this, that it's all for show.  That's always good to see.  Misery does love company.  Kevin reminds us, well actually Elton Beard pointed out that there was a post-impeachment Clinton censure motion in the Senate introduced by Diane Feinstein, which (Ta Dah!) went right down party lines.


Posted at 3/15/2006 2:49:17 pm by The Lib  

Ara
March 17, 2006   11:54 AM PST
 
You're with Kevin? I'm not.

I'm with <a href = "http://glenngreenwald.blogspot.com/2006/03/stirring-defense-of-indecision-and.html">Glenn Greenwald</a>.
Mark Adams, The Lib
March 18, 2006   02:55 AM PST
 
Oh, unlike Kevin or Glenn, I wasn't presuming to offer any advice to the Senators, only noting that both Kevin and I were using the same analogy, theater.

I was offering observations and I guess an implied wish that Russ were getting more support and noting that slowly but surely he is.

As for what should be done, you well know that I'm for throwing the entire Bush Crime Family in Levenworth. When I heard Feingold say he was going to introduce a censure motion, I stood up and cheered, (well actually I sat up, but I did cheer). I don't think for a minute that the GOP will gain anything out of this, and in that Digby is absolutely asture.

Russ took a stand and the rest of the Congress acted like it was a play. I guess Kevin was offering the analogy up as an excuse. I saw it more as an indictment about the seriousness, both Dem and GOP, with which they execute their oath of office -- not very much as we are seeing.

I'm much less pleased with Lindsay Graham's hypocrisy, managing the Clinton impeachment but offering Bush a way out.

Glenn is absolutely right in chastising the likes of Schumer and the others for not instantly supporting Bush's censure when they voted to censure Clinton.

Between Hillary and Lieberman trying to act like GOP Lite, and the rest of the caucus afraid to move before they focus group a decision, It's getting hard to stay patient.

I didn't say that I disapproved of Feingold's stunt, and I would hope if I were a Senator I would act much the same way, shaking up the establishment for the greater good.

I like stunts. Decent improv is much more entertaining than poorly rehearsed marionettes try to juggle. The problem is that when we play their game the GOP look as professional as the Muppets while we so often look like sock puppets in comparison.

Likewise, they don't do the off the cuff well. They can't take heckling, which is why you have to sign a loyalty oath to attend a speech by your president, and they don't handle stunts well (remember Terri Schiavo).

If anything we should do more stunts -- but let's not pretend they're something they're not.
    |

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments





Previous Entry

MAIN

Next Entry



Previous Entry

MAIN

Next Entry






<< March 2006 >>
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 01 02 03 04
05 06 07 08 09 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31

Notable Rants:

A Liberal Credo
Are The Religious Right?
Defining and Debunking Bushiology
September Tenth Thinking.
Rewarding Work, not Wealth
Howard Dean's Impecable Instincts
Reality Perceptions
Can We Agree On Just One Thing
1984 Trials of the Brave New Gulag
Christian Left
Order of the New World
Bush Rejects My Plan
The Plan
Rice's Silver Bullet
Socrates Always Asked the Unaskable
Why I'm not a Trial Lawyer
Dream Team
Rumsfeld: Left Times
UBL's Truce? Why Is He Still Alive?
Dream Team(pdf)
Eyes Wide Open






Since April 4, 2004





Listed on Blogwise

Blogarama - The Blog Directory
 



Blogdrive

 

 

Blogdrive